Force on Force
A campaign wargame of a war between the United States and Canada, built in the open, one module at a time. Every number has a source line. Every addition has a commit.
One counter per module. Top left is the version that added it. The two numbers at the bottom are the points it adds to “the Americans go home” when switched on, with everything else on: full invasion on the left, Alberta only on the right. v0.1.3.8, 3,000 paired runs. The four grey counters are the base game and cannot be switched off.
- The base game
- Forces
- Environment
- Economy
- Allies and third parties
- Geography
[0.0]Read this first
Force on Force is a grognard exercise. A grognard is a wargamer of the old school: someone who will argue for an evening about a supply rule. This is that kind of project, done with care. The inputs are sourced, the guesses are labelled as guesses, every addition is tested and committed, and the paper trail is public.
It is not a scientific model. Nothing here has been peer reviewed. Many of its coefficients are judgement. It has two historical backtests, both against Iraq, and one of them is in-sample. It has never been checked against a war like the one it describes, because there has not been one. Some parts are known to be wrong and are listed as such.
So read every percentage as what this rule set produces, not as a forecast. The model also assumes the war has already started. It says nothing about whether one will.
[1.0]Where the game stands
Three scenarios, each played thousands of times. The number counted is how often the United States gives up.
| Scenario | Outcome counted | Every module on | Every module off | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full invasion | The Americans go home | 71.4% | 56.4% | |
| Alberta only | The Americans go home | 61.6% | 35.9% | |
| No invasion | The US abandons the campaign | 34.4% | 12.7% |
3,000 paired runs per case, v0.1.3.8. Bars start at zero.
[2.0]Turn record
Each box is a tagged version. The version number is the rule case: 0.1.2.4 is the fourth addition to the second expansion of the first game. Follow any box to what was added, what it found, and the commit that did it.
- 0.1The base game: four layers
- 0.1.1Citizen mobilization
- 0.1.2Weather and season
- 0.1.2.2Seasonal insurgency
- 0.1.2.3Potash
- 0.1.2.4Oil
- 0.1.2.5Electricity exports
- 0.1.2.6Complex weather
- 0.1.2.6.1Bears and wildlife
- 0.1.2.7Supply chains and logistics
- 0.1.2.8NATO and allies
- 0.1.2.8.1Foreign small arms shipments
- 0.1.2.9All switches, measured together
- 0.1.2.10Test harness
- 0.1.2.11NATO split, member by member
- 0.1.2.12Allied air cover without ground troops
- 0.1.2.13A second war against a US ally
- 0.1.2.14Run traces and the replay page
- 0.1.2.14.1A run as a video
- 0.1.3.0Provinces as separate areas: the skeleton
- 0.1.3.1Population and geography by province
- 0.1.3.2Political geography by province
- 0.1.3.2.1Alberta baseline corrected
- 0.1.3.3Resources by province
- 0.1.3.4Where the US puts its troops, and provinces pacified one at a time
- 0.1.3.5Province pacification set from research
- 0.1.3.6Today's reserves against the 400,000 plan
- 0.1.3.7What the 400,000 does, and why
- 0.1.3.8The public site, and what each module is worth now
[3.0]What is in the box
[4.0]See it played
The replay page plays single wars month by month against all 2,000 runs of the same scenario: control by province, deaths, public support, a war diary.
Could 400,000 Canadians Stop a U.S. Invasion? I Ran the War 285,000 Times is a 16-minute walk through the v0.1.3.7 results on Canada's mobilization plan.