A grognard exercise, not a scientific model. What that means

Roadmap / 0.1.2.8.1

Foreign small arms shipments

Version 0.1.2.8.1, 11 Nov 2026. tag v0.1.2.8.1, commit 6a5eab2. File docs/RESULTS_v0.1.2.8.1_small_arms.md.
Written at this version and not revised since. Later versions may change these numbers; see the roadmap.

Switch: arms.enabled (off by default, neutral when off). Options: arms.black_market, arms.state_suppliers (auto follows the allied response reaching materiel; or force on/off), arms.us_blockade.
Runs: 2,000 per variant, seed 20261105, every earlier module on including NATO (response drawn). 18 tests pass.

What the module does (aggregate only; no routes, methods or weapon types)

A monthly ammunition-and-arms balance for the resistance: - Domestic stock: civilian firearms and ammunition plus cached military stocks last 6–24 months at full tempo. Canada has 2.47 million licence holders, about 6% of the population (RCMP 2025). When the stock is gone and nothing arrives, resistance lethality falls to 30–70% of normal. - US-origin black market: meets 20–60% of the need, with 10–35% stopped. The evidence on its scale is mixed: 91% of crime handguns recovered in Ontario in 2024 came from the US, but RCMP national tracing for 2023 found 80% of traced crime guns were domestic. - Foreign state shipments: open when the allied response reaches materiel, or when forced on. They meet 40–100% of the need; the US intercepts 20–50%, or 50–85% under a blockade. - Quality: military-grade small arms and light weapons add 10–40% lethality at full supply. - Exposure: a publicly exposed state shipment can rally US opinion. This is a narrative parameter with an uncertain sign.

Results — full annexation

Variant US deaths (mean) Lowest lethality (mean) Months with no stock (mean) US quits
Arms module off 1,892 1.00 0 66.1%
Isolated: no inflow 1,342 0.72 12.6 69.1%
Black market only 1,591 0.85 9.8 66.8%
Default (black market; state shipments if allies reach materiel) 1,705 0.89 7.6 70.3%
State shipments open 1,925 0.99 2.0 66.9%
State shipments under US blockade 1,822 0.95 6.6 67.2%
State shipments, no black market 1,789 0.95 7.5 66.8%

The Alberta detachment shows the same pattern (US deaths 180 isolated to 243 with open shipments; US quits 52–57%).

Findings

  1. Arms shipments change the body count, not the outcome. Cut off entirely, the resistance kills about 29% fewer US troops; with open state shipments it holds at full strength. The chance the US quits stays within the run-to-run noise (about ±2 points) in every variant.
  2. The clock matters more than the flow. Domestic stocks last about a year, and the median war lasts 17–20 months. Ammunition only starts to bind in the back half of a long occupation.
  3. The black market is a real floor. On its own it recovers about half the gap between isolation and full supply, and the US can't blockade its own border trade.
  4. A blockade works, partly. It roughly triples the months the resistance spends with no stock (2.0 → 6.6) but costs only ~5% of US deaths prevented, because the black market and the domestic stock fill in.
  5. Exposure risk is small in this model (1–2 exposures per war with a near-zero average effect). Whether "foreign powers arming insurgents" rallies Americans is another question for the narrative module.

Weakest parameters

All of them are modeller estimates. The most important are domestic_stock_months, ammo_floor, black_market_supply and quality_gain.

Sources

RCMP, 2025 and 2024 Commissioner of Firearms Reports; New York Times (Dec 2025) on US-origin crime guns in Ontario and Toronto; RCMP national tracing data via PolySeSouvient (June 2026); CBC (2025).