A grognard exercise, not a scientific model. What that means

Roadmap / 0.1.3.6

Today's reserves against the 400,000 plan

Version 0.1.3.6, 17 Nov 2026. tag v0.1.3.6, commit 7a6f189. File docs/RESULTS_v0.1.3.6_mobilization_levels.md.
Written at this version and not revised since. Later versions may change these numbers; see the roadmap.

Switch: canada_mobilization.mode (unchanged).
New option: canada_mobilization.level: today, plan (default, unchanged) or full. supplementary_strength overrides today's Supplementary Reserve count.
Runs: 3,000 paired runs per variant, every other module on, v0.1.3.5 defaults. 31 tests pass; harness checks pass.
Scope: aggregate strengths only. No units, sites or tactics.

Headline

  1. Against today's reserves, the full 400,000 plan raises the chance the US withdraws by 4 points in a full annexation (67% to 71%) and by 9 points in an Alberta detachment (54% to 63%).
  2. Nearly all of that gain arrives by the time the plan is about half filled. Going from the half-filled plan the model normally assumes to the full 400,000 adds nothing measurable in a full annexation and under 2 points in Alberta.
  3. The full plan costs more lives on both sides. US deaths rise 42% over today's case and Canadian deaths 39%.
  4. The exact size of today's Supplementary Reserve does not matter. 4,384, 6,700 or zero give the same result to a tenth of a point.

The three levels

Level Primary Reserve Supplementary Reserve People added to today's force Of whom armed
Today 23,561 (no expansion) 4,384 retired members, treated as trained and all armed 4,384 4,384
Plan as modelled (default since v0.1.1) 30 to 80% of 100,000 15 to 75% of 300,000, one week of training about 160,000 on average about 87,000
Full 400,000 100,000 300,000, one week of training 376,439 about 207,000 (20 to 70% can be armed)

"Today" also removes the effect the plan has on Canada's will to continue, because no mobilization scheme exists yet.

Results

Changes are against today's reserves, with 95% intervals.

Full annexation

Today Plan as modelled Full 400,000
US withdraws 66.8% 71.4% 71.1%
Change — +4.6 (+3.8 to +5.3) +4.3 (+3.6 to +5.0)
Canada capitulates 32.1% 27.5% 28.0%
US deaths 1,337 1,638 1,903
Canadian deaths 10,328 12,279 14,394
Average US control 57% 49% 43%
Troops the US needs at the start 524,000 603,000 709,000

Full against plan: −0.3 points (−0.6 to +0.1). No measurable difference.

Alberta detachment

Today Plan as modelled Full 400,000
US withdraws 54.3% 61.6% 63.3%
Change — +7.3 (+6.4 to +8.2) +9.0 (+8.0 to +10.1)
Canada capitulates 32.9% 27.4% 27.3%
Annexation consolidated 11.0% 9.2% 7.8%
US deaths 202 308 376
Canadian deaths 5,679 6,585 7,568
Troops the US needs at the start 47,000 62,000 71,000

Full against plan: +1.7 points (+1.2 to +2.3).

Economic coercion (no invasion)

Today Plan as modelled Full 400,000
US abandons the campaign 33.6% 34.4% 34.5%
Coercion succeeds 16.7% 13.4% 13.0%
Change in success — −3.3 (−3.9 to −2.7) −3.7 (−4.4 to −3.0)

Variations (full annexation)

Variant US withdraws US deaths Canadian deaths
No mobilization module at all 66.8% 1,325 10,272
Today with 6,700 in the Supplementary Reserve 66.7% 1,343 10,354
Full 400,000, one in five supplementary armed 71.3% 1,765 13,746
Full 400,000, all armed 70.6% 2,015 14,931

Arming all 400,000 is slightly worse for Canada than the plan as modelled (−0.8 points, −1.2 to −0.4).

Why the second half of the plan adds so little

Three things, and the first is my assumption, not evidence.

  1. The effect on Canada's will saturates. Since v0.1.1 the model has assumed that a plan half filled already gives the whole reduction in the chance Canada capitulates (10 to 40%). A full plan gets no more. If that effect kept growing with size, the full plan would do better than shown.
  2. More fighters means more Canadian dead, and Canadian dead push Canada toward capitulation. The full plan raises resistance (starting index 0.51 to 0.62) and cuts US control (49% to 43%), but Canadian deaths rise 17% over the plan as modelled. In a full annexation the two roughly cancel. That is why arming everyone comes out slightly worse.
  3. US withdrawal runs on public support, and deaths are one drain among several. US deaths rise 16% from plan to full; the oil, allied and economic pressures do not change.

In Alberta the national pool concentrates on one province, so the extra people still tell.

Limits

  • The saturation point in item 1 is a judgement. It decides most of the plan-against-full comparison.
  • The model does not charge Canada anything for mobilizing: no economic cost, no time to recruit. The plan has no date, and 300,000 volunteers would take years to enrol.
  • One week of training is represented only as low effectiveness (10 to 30% of a regular). Quality against quantity is not explored here; the territorial_core option exists for that.
  • "Today" is a floor. It assumes nothing is improvised once war starts.

Sources for today's strengths

  • Supplementary Reserve 4,384: May 2025 mobilization directive, as reported; the Ottawa Citizen still called it "the current 4,384" on 16 November 2026.
  • DND's Reserve Force components page says "about 6,700", undated.
  • No source was found for 4,135.
  • The same Ottawa Citizen article gives 25,780 part-time Primary Reservists; the model holds 23,561 (May 2025). Not changed in this version.